This product is sold at the Costco Garden Grove, California location. Please note that each location carries different items so it may not be sold at your local Costco and some items are only sold for a limited time. Products also rotate throughout the year to make room for new products so items may no longer be sold at the time of your visit due to it being discontinued. Prices may also vary. Be sure to check with your local Costco for availability.

Disclaimer: This page is not in any way affiliated with Costco and all opinions are of my own.

Price as of July 24, 2023

Costco Hershey Reese’s Dipped Animal Crackers . Item number 1681704 . Price $7.69

Hottest new product at Costco for 2023 !!

This is a very popular product at Costco but it is not a permanent item so if you see it, be sure to grab a bag before they are gone ! Due to its popularity though it will likely return at a later time.

Below are some comments and reviews on these Reese’s Dipped Animal Crackers from other Costco members:

GOOD REVIEWS

“Soooo good !!”

“These are soooo addicting!! 10/10 recommend NOT to purchase.”

“We ate ours in a day…“

“They taste like the peanut butter chocolate girl scout cookies. SO good”

“Thought they were good on the ride home. Then put the bag in the fridge. Yep! So good chilled “

“Super tasty, not too sweet which is nice.”

“I’m a huge reese’s fan so had to try them. And they were delicious”

“OMGEEEEE they are SOOOO GOOOODDDD!!!”

“Found them at Manahawkin, NJ location and they live up to the hype! 7.99 a bag…yes, I bought 2. Definitely recommend to the Reese’s lovers.”

“Dangerously good “

“Yes I grabbed a bag yesterday and I’m mad I didn’t grab 2! “

“Yep I’m almost 3/4 of the way thru my first bag!”

“Bought these last week and they’re almost gone! So so yummy!! “

“I’ve tried these and they are delicious”

“Crack in a bag!! So good!!

“These are so good!! I really hope when I finish the bag, there won’t be any left at my Costco! “

“I don’t normally eat Reese’s I bought these for family member, but these are good.”

“I got them in Sacramento and they are good. Hope to get my hands on another bag!”

“They are deadly!”

“We crushed a bag in less than a week.”

“Wish I would have bought more than 1 bag lol”

“I would say they’re popular.And they’re definitely AMAZING!”

“They taste like Girl scout peanut butter patties to me!”

“I just bought a bag and tried them today. Omg, they are addictive!”

“Just grabbed a bag today and our kids love them!”

“I bought these today in Dallas,Tx. Y’all were right they are so good!”

“Sooooo tasty!! We love them at our house!”

“These animal crackers are fantastic! Luv them!”

“Those cookies are delicious “

“They are so good my granddaughter picked them out. The Costco guy said those are a special and will not be restocked”

“I really liked them! They didn’t taste like Reese’s though.”

“Never have I ever loved a packaged cookie as much as I love these Reese’s animal cookies I got 6 bags and was stopped multiple times in the store asking if they are good, well obviously since I’m hoarding cookies now they expire in 2024 so m good “

“We FINALLY found these at the Sanatoga, PA location this past Saturday! And I can confirm… they are worth the hype “

“I think these taste just like butterfingers! “

“They sure are yummy”

“Bought 2 bags on Saturday. Promptly went back Sunday and bought 4 more.”

“They are really good! I hope they don’t discontinue them.”

“OMG We just got these yesterday, so delicious.”

“These are dangerous. They’re soooo good”

“Let’s just say I got 2 bags when I finally found them and my husband was like that’s a little much, now we have finished both bags and he says why didn’t you buy more of those!”

“I just bought some on Sunday, they are so addictive!!!!! Love them!”

“I’m not a huge fan of them, but my husband loves them.”

“I was secretly hoping these weren’t worth the hype so that I didn’t have to risk getting addicted. Unfortunately I’m disappointed that this wasn’t the case… and I ended up buying 2 more bags (from Costco in Hawthorne, CA).”

“THEY ARE SO GOOD!!!!!

I have to put three in my hand and then keep the bag out of sight and out of mind!!!…… for at least 30 mins haha. They are addicting!!!!”

“I think they taste like nutter butter cookies but still Dee-licious!”

“My son loves these. But he is 11 “

“I bought 1 bag when I found them…. Should have bought 8”

“They are amazing. Even better out of the fridge”

“DON”T OPEN THE BAG!!!! I bought them for my granddaughter, my husband opened the bag! They are 1/2 gone, and my granddaughter hasn’t been here yet!”

“Pretty dang good”

BAD REVIEWS

“We tried them. They were different than I expected. Ok, but I won’t buy them again”

“Honestly the animal crackers are not worth the hype”

“I was very underwhelmed with these and I looooooove Reeses”

“Eh they were just ok”

“They’re OK. Just ok. No biggie. “

“I like them but honestly no one else in my house did”

“To me they just taste like extra sweet animal crackers. It didn’t have that classic Reese’s peanut butter cup flavor.  Was super disappointed.”

“They were too sweet for me. I finished the bag because I have no will power and will eat anything sweet but I won’t buy these again. I prefer salty/sweet.”

“I think I’m the only one in the Costco universe that does not like these Reesie’s animal crackers! I think they taste like cheap store-bought nutty buddies.”

“I was super excited to find them at the Lakewood, CA location yesterday……until I tasted them. IMO the peanut butter is overwhelming. Would not buy again.”

“I felt like they taste like a Nutter Butter, I wasn’t impressed”