This product is sold at the Costco Garden Grove, California location. Please note that each location carries different items so it may not be sold at your local Costco and some items are only sold for a limited time. Products also rotate throughout the year to make room for new products so items may no longer be sold at the time of your visit due to it being discontinued. Prices may also vary. Be sure to check with your local Costco for availability.
Disclaimer: This page is not in any way affiliated with Costco and all opinions are of my own.
Price as of 08/29/22
Please note that the fresh baked pumpkin pies are seasonal and you can expect to see them in the bakery department starting usually in August .
Below are some comments and reviews on this fresh baked pumpkin pie from other Costco members:
GOOD REVIEWS
“Best pumpkin pie ever!!!”
“My favorite 
“
“So good and a great price. That would be good for breakfast. I’m going to try freezing slices.”
“yes, I freeze and defrost them every year when I get one. I believe it tells you on the label how to defrost properly.”
“One of my favorites!!”
“Mmmm so good! I add a walnut cinnamon sugar butter topping …warm it up and serve with vanilla ice cream or whipped cream…. because you know there just aren’t enough calories in it plain! LolololSooo dang good!”
“I ordered one from Instacart today, and they were out. Their pies are so damn big, slices don’t fit on a pie plate.”
“Bought a pie today too cuz I finished my last one lastnight 
it’s a necessity 
“
” I covered it in extra creamy cool whip. Yum.”
“My husband and I bought one already too! We’ve had it 3 nights in a row for dessert (oops). Best pumpkin pie ever!”
“Love their pumpkin 
pie 
! The best! I did see it went up by $1 now to $6.99, but still well worth it! Yum! 
“
“They have the best pumpkin pie! Can’t afford to make it homemade at that price”
“I love Costco’s pumpkin pie.”
“This is the best pumpkin pie ever. Love it.
“
“I bought an extra and froze it! lol”
“Can’t resist; I already dig into it. Two slices already gone !”
“i ate the whole thing myself”
“It’s amazing! Even the crust is awesome. Price is unbelievable! We froze over half of it.”
‘Just had a piece with pumpkin ice cream and whip cream. I need to make sure all was good!”
“love this for breakfast and hot coffee watching the snow fall”
‘I buy one almost every time I shop there”
“I look forward to their pumpkin pie every year! It’s the best!”
‘There is nothing like that first pie of the season. It is absolutely my favorite pumpkin pie”
‘OMG it’s my favorite pie it’s really good 
“
‘My husband. He will eat the whole damn thing.”
‘My husband’s favorite pie. Huge but reasonably priced”
‘The very best creamy pumpkin pie & the crust is delicious. Look forward every year when the pumpkin pies arrive. Yum .”
“Great deal for a decent pie. It’s huge and a great potluck item to bring.”
“We love them. If the crust gets soggy I’ll just put the whole tin on a pan and put it on the stove – med to low heat and cook the bottom more”
“So good and such a great price! 
“
“Love it and no longer bother making my own at that price!”
‘Delicious. Next best thing to homemade.”
“I’ve been buy one every week for 3 weeks! 
“
“I buy them every year. The best! Can’t make it that cheap.”
“Their pumpkin pies are HUGE and tasty… get em every year”
“BEST PUMPKIN PIE ANYWHERE’
“The BEST! Why make it from scratch???”
“They are the best pumpkin pies on the planet! You can’t make a small one yourself, for their price!”
“Best store bought pumpkin pie and for the cost!”
“Love it, very moist. It’s huge so after a few days, put it in the fridge or it will mold. Don’t forget the whip cream!”
“My favorite! Even better than my mom’s”
“It’s the only Pumpkin Pie I will eat. I don’t like Pumpkin Pie but I tolerate Costco’s. Now my husband will eat an entire pie in one day.”
“COSTCO makes the very best pumpkin pie!!”
“If you are used to sugary, super sweet pumpkin pie, then yes it is bland. I like Costco pumpkin for the very reason that it is not loaded with sickeningly sweet ingredients.”
“It’s the only non-homemade pumpkin pie I’ll buy. Yum!”
“The Costco pumpkin pies are by far my favorite pumpkin pie in the world. Seriously, they’re that good.”
“Costco has the best pumpkin pie and so reasonably priced.”
“Best pumpkin pie in town!”
“Súper delicious if you love pumpkin and a fantastic price “
“costco pumpkin pie is the only pumpkin pie I will ever eat…. every other pumpkin pie tastes awful..”
“Costco’s pies are enormous!”
BAD REVIEW
“Price is good but not really great tasting. I froze a lot of it. I wouldn’t buy it again”
“I bought one yesterday and it was watery, runny and the crust was soggy. 
“
“It was gritty to me I am guessing it’s the spice they used.”
‘Nope. Soggy crust. “
“eat it quick! its so moist it gets fuzzy fast.”
“They’re not dense enough for me… I like a deeper pumpkin and spice flavor. It’s probably how they’ve kept them so cheap.”
“Hit and miss … sometimes great and other time bland… 
“
“Pumpkin pie is one of my favorite things, but I do not like the Costco one.”
“Didn’t love it”
“Filling’s OK, but the crust is dull and soggy”
“Not wild about the crust, ( but I still make my own pie crust) but other than that it’s very Good !”
“The filling is good – but the crust is always raw!”
“I was wanting one so bad so bought one today and was so disappointed”
“Soggy crust”
“The price is great the taste is plain. Not much spice!”
“Yeah, I’m not a fan”
“After trying it, I must say I’m disappointed. It’s very bland, with little or no spice flavor, and the crust is just barely there. I won’t buy one again.”
“Too bland for me. I love my homemade one much better! It’s great to bring for a large crowd though!!”
“I’ve always had gritty sand like texture..”
“The one we bought last year was not baked long enough, so the filling was more like pudding.”
‘
