This product comes from the Garden Grove, California location. Please note that each location carries different items so it may not be sold at your local Costco and some items are only sold for a limited time . Products also rotate throughout the year to make room for new products so items may no longer be sold at the time of your visit due to it being discontinued. Prices may also vary. Be sure to check with your local Costco for availability.
Disclaimer: This page is not in any way affiliated with Costco and all opinions are of my own.
Price as of 11/12/22
Costco Pecan Pie is only seasonal . Item Number 15827
CAN YOU FREEZE PECAN PIE?
See our member’s responses below.
“Yes pecan pie freezes well.”
“Froze some last year and had it a couple weeks ago. It was amazing!”
“My Dad freezes his. He precuts it, lays a piece of plastic wrap on the top and then wraps it more plastic wrap. He cuts it so he can just take a piece when he wants it. He will pull a piece out and cover and put it in the fridge and wait till it thaws. Says it tastes just like it did when he brought it home.”
“I freeze them in quarters in plastic freezer bags. Perfect for the two of us for a couple of meals”
“So we hall know this pie is huge.We all know you want none of it to be wasted. So I had several good sized servings left and decided to try and freeze in individual servings to pull out when I wanted their pecan pie after the season. I sliced them. Put them , uncovered,on a plate, a baking pan , paper plate whatever. Let them freeze until filling pretty firm. Vacuum sealed in individual freeze saver bags.The one you see on the plate is thawed after frozen and tastes exactly like fresh! I know probably too much trouble for some but for those of us living with perhaps one or 2 family members, it works for me. When I want a piece of pecan pie and some coffee it is right there.”
Below are some comments and reviews on this Costco Pecan Pie from other Costco members:
GOOD REVIEWS
“I have always loved their pecan pies!”
“LOVE pecan pie but too big for our house 
. Me and MIL would be only ones who eat it. Hot with vanilla ice cream 
“
“Sooo good. Especially if you get one fresh the same day it’s baked.”
“I’ve bought it every year for my step dad and he loves it”
“The Pecan pie needs to be put in the refrigerator after you’ve taken your pieces out otherwise it will get runny. You cannot leave it out. We just bought one today and it’s delicious.”
“It’s the best pecan pie anywhere!!!”
“Tasty but I can get it out of pie tin. The crust edge won’t release from the tin.”
“Got one yesterday and it’s delicious”
“When I find we’re not going to finish all of the pie, and if the crust is starting to get soggy, I just scrape the filling out into individual dishes and serve with whipped cream, Pumpkin Pie pudding!”
“Put it in the fridge … then like on Vanilla ice cream next time you take it out “
“I get their pecan annually, I enjoy it. It has a much longer room temp. life. Of course, it’s a huge amount!”
“Pecan is amazing”
“I get pecan pie all the time”
“It was delicious. I ate way to many pieces”
“My Costco pecan pie was such a hit at thanksgiving, that I bought one again for Christmas. There were a few pieces left, but my husband and I are having a small each every night.”
” It’s indeed the best pecan pie. Lots of pecans and at a very good price”
“I love pecan pie and theirs is so dang good but absolutely humongous! 
“
“Pecan pie lasted 10 minutes before we dug in.”
“The pecan pie is decent. I would go to Baker’s Square though. We dont have them here anymore and I miss their pies!”
“Pecan was amazing 
“
“Pecan is good but honestly the nuts are whole and kinda hard”
“The pecan pies a really good”
“Pecan pie Costco is great”
“As someone from the south, I endorse it. It’s the best store made pecan pie.”
“As good as home made
“
“I love it so much I eat it for breakfast”
“Worth the price! It’s delicious and huge “
“Pecan is my favorite”
“the pecan pie is really good, we got it last year for thanksgiving”
“I got a pecan pie the other day. I may have already eaten half of it…”
“Pecan pies are my FAVORITE! We had Costco pecan pie at Thanksgiving. It’s definitely not the best – I think it has way too much vanilla.”
BAD REVIEWS
“I prefer Sam’s pecan pie.”
“My pie was not cooked all the way. Middle was liike watered down jelly… anyone else? Didn’t even get to eat it.”
“Costco’s pecan is too sweet and not pecan-y enough for my tastes.”
“The one and only one I have bought was nasty, no flavor. Will not buy again. Of course I was raised on homemade ones.”
“Busted open the pecan pie tonight early, and sadly it was awful. The crust fell apart, not enough pecans, and the filling was all soupy. First time ever getting a crappy Costco pie.”
“Too sweet with too much filling and not enough pecans to balance..”
“The pecan pie is good but I have gotten a few that were not cooked all the way.”
“Pecan is very very sweet”
“Costco’s pecan pie was terrible. Very disappointed”
“Threw the entire Costco pecan pie in the trash.”
“We love Pecan Pie, just not Costco’s version. There are much better pecan pies you can get at a local bakery or super market.’
“Pecan is yuk!! I bought it once.. tried it… took off the pecans and dumped it. 
“
“Pecan pie disgusting sweet”
“I prefer pecan pie from a local bakery. I find the gooey part to be very thick. And of course it’s HUGE
“
“I don’t like pecan pie. To much sugar. To sweet”
“Pecan pie is my fav but didn’t care for this one. If not homemade…don’t judge …but I have to say Cracker Barrel has really good chocolate pecan pie.”
